Discussion in 'Submission Room' started by Ivanski, Jan 25, 2011.
Hello all,I am very excited in joining Piano Society and hearing all of such talented musicians!
Re: 4 Improvisations
I'm a bit puzzled by this corny prelude elaboration and the rather trite Oberek. Based on these I would say that you have considerable dexterity but don't care too much for classical style and accuracy. I then found out you are a piano major and respected accompanist and that puzzled me even more. Why submit stuff like this ? I did like parts of the Raindrops (though the sound is terrible and not all of it is interesting), and the tango-dream, while far too long, seems to have a certain intellectual quality which may appeal to the improvisers here. Some gamelan-like sounds in these pieces caught my ear.
All in all, you seem like 4 different people to me here. No doubt you have lurked around this site for a while and have an idea of the repertoire and quality that we appreciate here ? These pieces are not really our 'cup of tea' . . .
Sorry to sound a little dismissive. I hope you can submit something more appropriate and better recorded.
Thank you for your honest reply,that's just what I needed to hear!
I will continue here as an avid listener and learner,for the time being.
Good, welcome !
Though why did you delete your submissions ? Maybe others had wanted to comment too.
Separate names with a comma.